Our Sea, Our Sovereignty: Eritrea Will Not Be Redrawn
By: David Yeh
Let us be clear from the first line. Eritrea did not assert its legitimate right of decolonization and win its independence – first denied in the 1940s on the altar of overriding external interests – to become again a footnote in someone else’s geopolitical paper. We did not bury our sons, daughters, mothers, fathers, sisters, and brothers, endure thirty years of war, and vote almost unanimously in 1993 to free ourselves, only to be told thirty years later that our coastline is a regional common, our sovereignty is an obstacle, and our stability is a problem to be managed by others.
These heroic acts of national liberation were undertaken to redress a historical mistake: the transgression meted on Eritrea in the 1940s when its right of decolonization – that applied to the other Italian colonies of Libya and Somalia – was uniquely suppressed in the case of Eritrea on the altar of “overriding super power geopolitical interests”.
The recent wave of commentary by PP minions and activists about the Southern Red Sea repeats the same old story with new academic language. It paints the Bab el- Mandab as a zone of chaos, Eritrea as “isolated and repressive”, and Ethiopia’s hunger for a sea port as a “legitimate aspiration that reasonable people must accommodate”. It is a false story, and it must be answered plainly.
Eritrea is the Anchor; Not the Problem
We are told the Southern Red Sea is unstable because of internal crises, interstate disputes, and non-state actors. What is never said is who has kept the Eritrean coast stable while war raged in Yemen, Sudan remained embroiled in externally induced civil war, Somalia struggled with terrorism.
Eritrea has not exported war. Eritrea has not collapsed. Eritrea has not invited a new foreign base every season to do its fighting for it. Our coastline from Ras Qesar to Ras Dumera, more than 1,000 kilometers of Red Sea shore, has remained secure, sovereign, and open to legitimate commerce. That is not an accident. That is the result of a disciplined state, a disciplined people, and a national policy that refuses to rent our sovereignty to the highest bidder.
When analysts speak of excessive external influence reducing domestic decision making, they are describing everyone except Eritrea. We are the one state in the Horn that has consistently said no to being a proxy. No to foreign military tutelage. No to aid conditionality that demands we surrender our economic model. No to a Red Sea security architecture designed in some foreign countries without the littoral states at the table. If the region suffers from external militarization, it is not because Eritrea invited it. It is because others have turned our sea into a parking lot for foreign navies while preaching about cooperation.
The Caricature of the “Isolated, Repressive” Eritrea
The same PP minions and hired lobbyists/Conflict Entrepreneurs always repeat the same chorus: Eritrea locked its international relations for years and is continuously hit by migration due to a “repressive political system”. This is not analysis. It is propaganda repeated until it sounds like fact. Eritrea did not lock itself out. Eritrea was locked out by sanctions, by the UN Security Council’s unjust and illegal measures from 2009 to 2018, by the deliberate strangling of our economy, and by a hostile information war waged by those who could not accept that a small African nation would choose self-reliance over dependency.
Our youth do not leave because Eritrea is cruel. They leave because Europe and America opened doors, paid smugglers, and built an entire pull economy for migration, while sanctions denied our youth jobs, investment, and technology at home. To blame Eritrea alone for migration is to erase the hands that imposed the sanctions and the hands that profit from the exodus.
Ask any honest observer: where in the Horn do you find free education from primary school to university, free healthcare, no institutionalized ethnic polarization tearing the country apart, no clan warlords, no religious civil war? That is Eritrea. We are grappling with economic challenges because we were destroyed by war and then sanctioned, not because we are ungovernable or resourceless. We are proud because we built schools, hospitals, dams, and roads with our own hands while others built their capitals with foreign handouts and loans. To call us “repressive” is to insult a people who chose discipline over chaos, and unity over ethnic fragmentation that has consumed some of our neighbors.

There Is No Legitimate Ethiopian Claim To Massawa Or Assab
Now we come to the most dangerous line of all: that Ethiopia’s quest for sovereign sea access is legitimate because it once administered Massawa and Assab and once had a navy. Administered is the word of an occupier.
Eritrea was unfairly federated with Ethiopia against the will of its people in 1952, then illegally annexed in 1962. For thirty years, Ethiopia occupied Eritrean ports as a colonial power occupies a colony. The fact of occupation does not create a right of ownership. If it did, then every colonizer could claim eternal rights to the lands it once stole.
Our people fought and died to end that occupation for thirty years. The referendum of 1993 was not a gift from Addis Ababa. It was the legal/diplomatic confirmation of a liberation already won on the battlefield. In that referendum, Eritreans voted for independence, and with independence came full sovereignty over Massawa and Assab. Ethiopia became landlocked because Eritrea became free. That is the price of freedom, and it is not negotiable.
Former Prime Minister Pascal Affi N’Guessan may call this aspiration legitimate from Abidjan. We respect his desire for African unity. But African unity is not built by giving one country’s territory to another to soothe its sense of loss. True unity is built on respect for borders, respect for referendums, and respect for the blood that was shed to draw those borders in freedom. Unity in ideas, unity in sharing, does not mean unity in surrendering our coast. We will share our ports through commerce, through transit agreements, through win-win economic cooperation, as we have always been willing to do. We will never share our sovereignty through cession, lease of sovereign territory, or a corridor carved out by force or pressure.
Ethiopia has a legitimate right to trade. It does not have a legitimate right to own. It has access to Djibouti, to Berbera, to Lamu, to Port Sudan. What it wants is not access. It wants possession. And possession of Eritrean land will never be on the table.
On Borders, Dialogue, And Real Cooperation
We are told border disputes between Ethiopia and Somalia, Ethiopia and Eritrea, Eritrea and Djibouti, and others are frequent sources of tension. Let us speak truthfully about Eritrea’s borders. Our border with Ethiopia was delimited more than a century ago; through the Colonial Treaties of 1900, 1902 and 1908. This border remained intact and unaltered during the Italian colonial period (1989-1941); the British Military Administration of Eritrea (1941- 52) after the defeat of Italy in the Second World War; and the UN-imposed Federal Arrangement which specifically recognized this boundary.
The same border was essentially endorsed and delimited and virtually demarcated by the Eritrea-Ethiopia Boundary Commission EEBC) in 2002 and 2007 respectively after the 1998- 2000 border war between the two countries when the incumbent Ethiopian regime wrongly claimed Badme and some other border areas as “sovereign Ethiopian territories”. The border litigation processes, that took place in the Hague by the EEBC in the aftermath of the border war, were specifically anchored on the Algiers Agreement that stipulated the delimitation and demarcation of the border on the basis of the three Colonial Treaties (1900,1902,1908) and applicable international law.
Ethiopia refused to implement the EEBC Arbitral Award for sixteen years in spite of the unequivocal provisions of the Algiers Agreement that stipulated, in advance, the Arbitral Award as “ final and binding” to both parties. It was Ethiopia that occupied Badme in violation of international law, not Eritrea. When peace finally came in 2018, it was because Eritrea stood firm on law, not because we begged for it.
Real cooperation in the Red Sea cannot be built on threats, on memorandums signed over our heads, or on meetings in some foreign capitals, where the coastal owner is treated as an obstacle. Real cooperation begins with a simple principle: the Red Sea belongs to the Red Sea states. Its security must be led by its littoral peoples. Its economic benefits must serve its littoral peoples first.
Eritrea is ready for that cooperation. We have always been ready. We will build roads, power lines, and trade corridors with Ethiopia, with Sudan, with Djibouti, with Somalia, with Yemen, with Saudi Arabia. We will sit at any table where we are respected as equals. But we will not sit at a table where our existence is debated as a problem, where our ports are discussed as if they are up for redistribution, and where our sovereignty is treated as a relic of the past.
The Bab el-Mandab is our gate. It is our history. It is our future. It is not a corridor for others to divide. Eritrea stands. Eritrea will not bend.


